What's the best way to disclose influencer marketing partnerships legally?
Answer
The best way to disclose influencer marketing partnerships legally requires strict adherence to Federal Trade Commission (FTC) guidelines, with a focus on transparency, clarity, and platform-specific compliance. Influencers and brands must disclose any "material connection" (financial, employment, or personal relationships) whenever endorsing products or services, ensuring followers can easily identify paid promotions. Disclosures must be "clear and conspicuous" - placed prominently in content (not buried in hashtags or profile pages) and written in the same language as the endorsement. The FTC emphasizes that disclosures should be unavoidable, whether in captions, videos, or livestreams, with specific rules for different content formats. Failure to comply risks legal action, including class-action lawsuits, as seen with brands like Revolve and Shein.
Key legal requirements include:
- Mandatory disclosure of all paid partnerships, gifted products, or financial relationships, regardless of compensation type [1]
- Platform-specific placement - disclosures must appear at the beginning of captions (first 3 lines on Instagram), on-screen during videos, or verbally in audio content [7]
- Clear language using terms like "advertisement," "paid partnership," or "ad" rather than ambiguous phrases like "thanks to [brand]" [9]
- Consistent application - every single paid post requires disclosure, with no exceptions for "small" collaborations [4]
The legal landscape also requires contractual agreements between brands and influencers that specify disclosure obligations, content rights, and compliance responsibilities. Both parties share liability for non-compliance, making proper documentation essential.
Legal Compliance Framework for Influencer Disclosures
FTC Disclosure Requirements and Best Practices
The Federal Trade Commission's Endorsement Guides form the legal foundation for influencer marketing disclosures in the United States. These rules apply to all endorsement relationships where consumers wouldn't reasonably expect a connection between the influencer and brand. The FTC's position is clear: "When there's a connection between an endorser and the marketer that consumers would not expect and it would affect how consumers evaluate the endorsement, that connection should be disclosed" [1]. This includes not just cash payments but also free products, discounts, or any other material benefits.
For effective compliance, influencers must follow these specific requirements:
- Timing and placement: Disclosures must appear before consumers engage with content. On Instagram, this means within the first three lines of a caption (before the "more" cutoff). In videos, disclosures must appear on-screen for the duration of the endorsement message and be repeated if the product appears multiple times [7][9]
- Language clarity: Terms like "advertisement," "paid promotion," or "sponsored" are acceptable, while vague phrases like "collaboration" or "partnership" without financial context are insufficient. The FTC explicitly states that "partner" alone doesn't convey the necessary meaning [1]
- Visual prominence: Disclosures must stand out from other text. Using contrasting colors, larger fonts, or separate disclosure boxes meets this requirement. On platforms with built-in disclosure tools (like Instagram's "Paid Partnership" tag), using these features satisfies the prominence requirement [8]
- Consistency across platforms: Each social media platform has specific disclosure tools that influencers must use. Instagram's "Paid Partnership" label, YouTube's disclosure settings, and TikTok's "Branded Content" toggle all meet FTC standards when properly configured [4]
The FTC provides concrete examples of proper disclosures:
- For Instagram posts: "ad [BrandName] - I love how this [product] helps me [benefit]" at the very beginning of the caption
- For YouTube videos: "This video is sponsored by [BrandName]" stated clearly at the start, with on-screen text reinforcement
- For TikTok: Using the platform's "Branded Content" disclosure tool plus verbal disclosure in the first 3 seconds [1]
Legal experts emphasize that the disclosure must match the platform's user experience. As noted in Honigman's legal guide: "The disclosure must be formatted to match the platform's user experience: up-front in the first lines of an Instagram caption, on-screen for the duration of a YouTube video's endorsement message, or verbally stated at the beginning of a podcast" [7]. This platform-specific approach ensures consumers see the disclosure regardless of how they engage with the content.
Contractual Obligations and Liability Protection
While proper disclosures satisfy FTC requirements, comprehensive legal protection requires formal contracts between brands and influencers. These agreements should explicitly outline disclosure obligations, content ownership, and compliance responsibilities. The Influencer Marketing Factory's legal guide identifies five essential contract elements that directly relate to disclosure requirements:
- Disclosure clauses: Contracts must specify exactly how and where influencers will disclose the partnership, including required hashtags, placement rules, and platform-specific tools. Sample language might state: "Influencer agrees to disclose the brand relationship using 'ad' or '[BrandName] Partner' in the first 120 characters of all social media captions" [3]
- Compliance warranties: Both parties should warrant that they understand and will comply with all applicable laws, including FTC guidelines. Brands often include clauses like: "Influencer represents that all content will comply with FTC Endorsement Guides and platform-specific advertising policies" [8]
- Indemnification provisions: These protect both parties from legal consequences of non-compliance. A typical clause might read: "Influencer agrees to indemnify Brand against any claims arising from Influencer's failure to properly disclose the brand relationship as required by law" [3]
- Content approval processes: Many contracts require brand approval of posts before publication to ensure proper disclosures. This might include: "Influencer will submit all proposed content to Brand for disclosure compliance review at least 48 hours prior to scheduled posting" [8]
- Termination for non-compliance: Contracts should specify that failure to disclose properly constitutes a material breach, allowing immediate termination. Example language: "Brand may terminate this Agreement immediately if Influencer fails to include required disclosures in any posted content" [3]
The legal risks of inadequate disclosures extend beyond FTC enforcement. Class-action lawsuits have targeted brands like Revolve and Shein for failing to disclose paid endorsements, with plaintiffs arguing that undisclosed influencer posts constitute deceptive advertising practices [2]. These cases demonstrate that both brands and influencers face substantial liability. As legal expert Natasha Merchant notes: "The FTC can fine brands up to $50,120 per violation for deceptive endorsements, and influencers can be held personally liable for non-compliance" [8].
For additional protection, legal experts recommend:
- Documenting all communications about disclosure requirements between brands and influencers
- Conducting regular compliance audits of influencer content
- Including disclosure requirements in influencer briefs and style guides
- Providing training on FTC guidelines for all marketing team members [7]
The University of Miami's best practices guide emphasizes that proper disclosure isn't just about legal compliance but also about maintaining audience trust: "Transparency in influencer marketing builds long-term credibility with consumers and protects brand reputation" [6]. This reputational aspect makes proper disclosure a business imperative beyond just legal requirements.
Sources & References
theinfluencermarketingfactory.com
honigman.com
tailwindapp.com
Discussions
Sign in to join the discussion and share your thoughts
Sign InFAQ-specific discussions coming soon...