What's the best way to test mechanical keyboards before buying?
Answer
Testing a mechanical keyboard before purchasing is essential to ensure the right fit for your typing style, ergonomic needs, and personal preferences. The process involves evaluating switch types, keyboard sizes, and build quality—factors that significantly impact user experience. While in-person testing at retail stores like Microcenter is ideal, alternatives like switch testers, online research, and community recommendations provide practical solutions when physical testing isn’t possible. For beginners, prioritizing switch feel and keyboard layout often yields the best results, as these elements directly affect comfort and productivity.
Key takeaways for effective testing:
- Switch testers (available for ~$4) allow you to compare linear, tactile, and clicky switches before committing to a full keyboard [1][5].
- Retail stores (e.g., Microcenter, Best Buy) offer hands-on testing for select models, though availability varies by location [1][5].
- Keyboard meetups and online communities (e.g., r/MechanicalKeyboards) provide access to niche or custom keyboards not found in stores [5].
- Pre-built keyboards (e.g., Keychron K2, Royal Kludge RK84) are recommended for beginners due to their balance of quality and affordability [3][10].
How to Test Mechanical Keyboards Before Buying
Evaluating Switch Types: The Core of Keyboard Feel
The switch type is the most critical factor in a mechanical keyboard’s performance, dictating typing resistance, noise, and feedback. Mechanical switches are categorized into three primary types—linear, tactile, and clicky—each suited to different use cases. Linear switches (e.g., Cherry MX Red) offer smooth keystrokes ideal for gaming, while tactile switches (e.g., Cherry MX Brown) provide a subtle bump for typing accuracy. Clicky switches (e.g., Cherry MX Blue) deliver audible feedback but may be disruptive in shared spaces [7][9].
To test switches effectively:
- Use a switch tester: These kits contain 4–10 switches mounted on a small board, allowing side-by-side comparison. Prices range from $4–$20, making them a cost-effective way to sample switches before buying a full keyboard [1][5].
- Visit a retail store: Stores like Microcenter and Best Buy often display mechanical keyboards for testing. Focus on pressing keys at different angles to gauge consistency and comfort [5].
- Attend keyboard meetups: Local or virtual meetups (organized via Reddit or Discord) let you test high-end or custom keyboards not available in stores. These events are particularly useful for evaluating rare switches like Topre or Hall Effect [5].
- Watch comparison videos: Channels like KeebNews and RTINGS.com provide in-depth switch sound tests and typing demonstrations, which can help narrow down preferences if in-person testing isn’t possible [3][8].
For beginners, tactile switches (e.g., Gateron Brown) are often recommended as a middle ground between typing feedback and noise control. Gamers may prefer linear switches for rapid keypresses, while writers might opt for clicky switches for satisfying auditory feedback [7].
Choosing the Right Keyboard Size and Layout
Keyboard size directly impacts desk space, portability, and functionality. Full-size keyboards (100%) include a numpad and function row, ideal for data entry or accounting, while tenkeyless (TKL, 80%) and compact (60%) layouts save space and reduce mouse travel distance. Intermediate sizes like 75% and 65% offer a balance between functionality and footprint [3][7].
Key considerations for testing layouts:
- Desk space: Measure your workspace to ensure the keyboard fits comfortably alongside your mouse and other peripherals. A full-size keyboard requires ~18–22 inches of width, while a 60% keyboard may only need 12 inches [7].
- Key accessibility: Test how often you use the numpad, arrow keys, or function row. For example, programmers may prioritize a 65% layout with dedicated arrow keys, while gamers might prefer a TKL for extra mouse room [3].
- Portability: If you travel frequently, compact keyboards (e.g., Royal Kludge RK61) weigh under 2 lbs and fit easily in backpacks. Wireless models add convenience but may introduce latency for competitive gaming [8].
- Hot-swappable options: Keyboards like the GMMK or Keychron Q series allow switch changes without soldering, making them ideal for experimenting with different switch types over time [3][8].
Popular beginner-friendly layouts include:
- Keychron K2 (75%): Combines compactness with dedicated arrow keys and a numpad layer [3].
- Royal Kludge RK84 (75%): Wireless option with PBT keycaps for durability [8].
- NuPhy Air75 V2 (75%): Low-profile design with ergonomic angles for extended typing sessions [8].
For testing layouts without physical access, use online keyboard simulators (e.g., keyboard-layout-editor.com) to visualize key placements or watch unboxing videos that demonstrate typing on different sizes [3].
Sources & References
Discussions
Sign in to join the discussion and share your thoughts
Sign InFAQ-specific discussions coming soon...