What's subvocalization and how to reduce it?
Answer
Subvocalization is the silent, internal pronunciation of words in your mind while reading—a natural process that helps comprehension but often limits reading speed to the pace of speech (150-250 words per minute) [1][4]. While it serves as a cognitive tool for understanding complex material, particularly for struggling readers or non-native speakers, it becomes a bottleneck for those aiming to read faster or process information more efficiently [1][9]. The key challenge lies in balancing speed and comprehension: eliminating subvocalization entirely is neither practical nor beneficial, but reducing it can unlock significant gains in reading efficiency [4][6].
To minimize subvocalization effectively, research-backed techniques focus on distracting the inner voice, training visual processing, and optimizing reading habits. The most evidence-supported methods include:
- Occupying the inner voice with counting, humming, or chewing gum to disrupt silent speech [1][3][10]
- Chunking words by reading groups of 3-5 words at once instead of individual words, which bypasses the need to "hear" each term [1][5]
- Guiding eye movement with a pointer (finger or pen) to reduce regression and force faster visual processing [4][10]
- Pre-scanning text to identify unfamiliar words or structure before detailed reading, reducing pauses for subvocalization [1][10]
Critically, complete elimination of subvocalization may impair comprehension by 10-20%, especially for dense or technical material [8]. The goal is strategic reduction—training the brain to rely more on visual recognition and less on auditory reinforcement, particularly for experienced readers [1][6].
Understanding and Reducing Subvocalization
The Science and Trade-offs of Subvocalization
Subvocalization is not merely a "bad habit" but a cognitive mechanism tied to how the brain processes language. Neurological studies suggest it activates the same regions as spoken speech, which is why it feels automatic and difficult to suppress [6]. For most readers, it serves two primary functions:
- Comprehension aid: It reinforces meaning by engaging auditory memory, particularly for abstract or unfamiliar terms. Non-native English speakers, for example, often rely on subvocalization to bridge gaps in vocabulary [9].
- Speed limiter: The average person speaks at 150-250 words per minute (wpm), so subvocalizing caps reading speed at this rate unless consciously overridden [4].
However, the relationship between subvocalization and comprehension is nuanced. While it helps with:
- Retaining complex ideas in technical or academic texts [7]
- Learning new languages by reinforcing pronunciation [9]
it becomes counterproductive for:
- Skimming or reviewing familiar material, where visual scanning alone suffices [6]
- Speed reading goals, as it creates a "bottleneck" that prevents processing text at the brain’s potential speed (estimated at 400-600 wpm for visual recognition) [8]
Attempts to eliminate subvocalization entirely often backfire. A 2015 analysis found that readers who suppressed it completely saw comprehension drop by up to 20%, while those who reduced it strategically (e.g., subvocalizing only key terms) maintained 80-90% comprehension at higher speeds [8]. This aligns with the "speed-comprehension tradeoff" observed in speed reading research, where gains beyond 500-600 wpm typically sacrifice understanding [6].
Practical Techniques to Reduce Subvocalization
Reducing subvocalization requires retraining the brain to prioritize visual processing over auditory reinforcement. The most effective methods combine distraction techniques with structured practice:
- Distract the Inner Voice
The principle here is to occupy the mental "channel" used for subvocalization with alternative stimuli. Studies and anecdotal reports highlight:
- Chewing gum or humming: Creates physical vibrations that interfere with silent speech. A Reddit user reported success by humming at a constant pitch, which "blocks" the ability to subvocalize [3].
- Counting or repeating a phrase: Saying "1-2-3-4" silently or repeating a word like "the" while reading forces the inner voice to focus on the repetition instead of the text [1][8].
- Instrumental music: Lyric-free music at 60-80 bpm (e.g., baroque or ambient) can mask subvocalization without distracting from the content [4][10].
- Train Visual Chunking
Subvocalization thrives when readers fixate on individual words. Breaking this habit involves:
- Reading word groups: Practice capturing 3-5 words in a single glance. For example, instead of reading "The | quick | brown | fox," train to see "The quick brown | fox jumps" as two chunks [1][5].
- Using a pointer: Guiding your eyes with a finger or pen at a pace faster than subvocalization (e.g., 300+ wpm) forces the brain to process visually. This reduces regression (re-reading) by 30-50% [4].
- Backward reading drills: Reading sentences backward (e.g., "fox brown quick the") disrupts the left-to-right subvocalization habit and builds visual flexibility [5].
- Pre-Process the Text
Unfamiliar words or complex sentences trigger stronger subvocalization. Mitigate this by:
- Scanning for keywords: Spend 10-20 seconds identifying bold terms, headings, or unfamiliar vocabulary before reading in detail [1].
- Previewing structure: Note paragraph lengths, bullet points, or diagrams to create a mental "map" of the content, reducing pauses for subvocalization [10].
- Skimming first: Read the first and last sentences of each paragraph to grasp the main idea, then return for details. This technique alone can increase speed by 20-40% while maintaining comprehension [6].
- Leverage Technology
Digital tools can enforce habits that counteract subvocalization:
- Speed reading apps: Apps like Spreeder or AccelaReader display words in rapid succession (e.g., 400+ wpm), making subvocalization impossible at higher speeds [1].
- RSVP (Rapid Serial Visual Presentation): This method flashes words one at a time at a fixed point, eliminating eye movement and subvocalization triggers [8].
- Text-to-speech overlap: Listening to an audiobook while reading the same text at 1.5x speed can help sync visual and auditory processing, gradually reducing reliance on the inner voice [4].
Critical Notes on Practice
- Gradual progression: Start by reducing subvocalization for 1-2 sentences, then expand to paragraphs. Sudden suppression often leads to comprehension loss [5].
- Material selection: Begin with familiar or simple texts (e.g., news articles) before applying techniques to technical documents [7].
- Comprehension checks: After each session, summarize the main points to ensure retention isn’t sacrificed for speed [6].
Sources & References
speedreadinglounge.com
irisreading.com
scotthyoung.com
forum.artofmemory.com
news.ycombinator.com
bookriot.com
Discussions
Sign in to join the discussion and share your thoughts
Sign InFAQ-specific discussions coming soon...