What's interleaving and how does it improve learning?
Answer
Interleaving is a research-backed learning technique where students alternate between different but related topics, problems, or skills within a single study session, rather than focusing on one area at a time (a method called "blocking"). This approach forces the brain to continuously retrieve and apply knowledge in varied contexts, which significantly enhances long-term retention, problem-solving abilities, and the capacity to distinguish between similar concepts. Studies across mathematics, physics, and other disciplines show interleaving improves test performance by 50-125% compared to traditional blocked practice, despite students often perceiving it as more difficult [8]. Cognitive psychologists explain that interleaving strengthens memory associations by requiring active discrimination between concepts, while blocking tends to create an illusion of mastery that fades quickly [3][6].
Key findings from the research:
- Interleaving improves long-term retention by forcing the brain to retrieve information repeatedly in different contexts [7][8]
- Students using interleaving score 50-125% higher on surprise tests than those using blocked practice [8]
- The technique works across skill levels, including for students with lower prior knowledge [6]
- Many learners mistakenly believe blocked practice is more effective, despite evidence showing interleaving's superiority [6][8]
How Interleaving Transforms Learning Processes
The Cognitive Science Behind Interleaving's Effectiveness
Interleaving's power comes from how it engages fundamental cognitive processes differently than traditional study methods. When learners alternate between topics, their brains must repeatedly retrieve and reapply knowledge in new contexts, which creates stronger memory traces. Research in cognitive psychology shows this approach enhances what scientists call "discriminative contrast" - the ability to distinguish between similar concepts [3]. For example, when students alternate between calculating volumes of cones, cylinders, and spheres (rather than doing all cone problems together), they must actively decide which formula applies to each shape, reinforcing their understanding of the underlying differences [1].
The technique also leverages several key memory mechanisms:
- Retrieval practice: Each switch between topics forces recall of previously studied material, strengthening memory [7]
- Contextual interference: The "desirable difficulty" of jumping between topics creates stronger learning than the ease of blocked practice [6]
- Relational processing: Students naturally compare and contrast concepts when interleaving, building deeper connections [8]
- Attention focusing: The varied practice maintains higher engagement than repetitive drilling [5]
A landmark study with physics students demonstrated these effects clearly: those using interleaved homework assignments showed 50% better performance on immediate tests and 125% improvement on delayed tests compared to blocked practice groups [8]. Notably, these gains persisted even when students reported feeling less confident during interleaved practice, suggesting the technique creates learning that feels harder but produces better outcomes.
Practical Applications Across Subjects and Settings
Interleaving's versatility makes it applicable across diverse learning scenarios, from individual study sessions to classroom instruction. In mathematics, the technique shows particularly strong results when students mix problem types that require different solution strategies. For instance, alternating between algebra word problems, geometry proofs, and trigonometry calculations in a single session helps students develop the cognitive flexibility to recognize which mathematical tools apply to different situations [1][7]. Similarly, music students benefit from interleaving scales, chords, and rhythm exercises rather than practicing each in isolation [2].
Educators can implement interleaving through several evidence-based strategies:
- Cumulative quizzes: Mixing questions from current and previous units forces spaced retrieval [7]
- Station rotations: Setting up different practice stations where students cycle through varied problems [9]
- Integrated projects: Combining multiple skills in real-world applications (e.g., a science project requiring math calculations, writing, and data analysis) [9]
- Time-limited topic switches: Alternating subjects every 20-30 minutes during study sessions [5]
- Review sessions: Structuring review time to revisit multiple topics in a single session rather than one at a time [5]
Important considerations for effective implementation include:
- Starting with moderately difficult material (interleaving shows less benefit for very easy or very hard tasks) [6]
- Avoiding overly rapid switching which can become confusing [5]
- Gradually increasing the complexity of interleaved material as students progress [2]
- Combining interleaving with other evidence-based techniques like spaced repetition and self-testing [1]
The technique's effectiveness extends beyond academic subjects. Athletes using interleaved practice (mixing different skills in training) show better game-time performance than those using blocked drills [2]. Similarly, language learners benefit from alternating vocabulary, grammar, and conversation practice rather than focusing on one area per session [3]. This cross-domain applicability stems from interleaving's foundation in how human memory and skill acquisition fundamentally work.
Sources & References
psychology.ucsd.edu
blog.alexanderfyoung.com
ctl.wustl.edu
learningscientists.org
learning.uiowa.edu
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Discussions
Sign in to join the discussion and share your thoughts
Sign InFAQ-specific discussions coming soon...