What's the best way to migrate from other email platforms to Mailchimp?
Answer
Migrating to Mailchimp from another email platform requires careful planning to ensure data integrity, compliance, and a smooth transition. The process involves exporting contacts, setting up proper audience structures, and maintaining email deliverability. Mailchimp provides built-in tools and resources to streamline this migration, but success depends on following best practices for data organization and permission management.
Key findings from the sources:
- Pre-migration preparation is critical: Export contacts from your current platform in CSV format and review compliance requirements (opt-ins, suppression lists) [1] [2].
- Domain authentication (SPF/DKIM) and 2-factor authentication must be configured to protect deliverability and account security [2].
- Single audience structure is recommended for most users, with tags/groups for segmentation rather than multiple lists [1] [5].
- Post-migration engagement strategies, such as re-introduction emails for inactive contacts, help maintain sender reputation [2].
Step-by-Step Migration to Mailchimp
Pre-Migration: Data Preparation and Compliance
Before importing contacts, ensure your data meets Mailchimp’s compliance standards and is structured for optimal performance. This phase prevents deliverability issues and legal risks.
Start by exporting all contact data from your current platform. For Constant Contact users, this involves navigating to the "Contacts" section and downloading a CSV file containing email addresses, custom fields, and engagement metrics [5]. Other platforms like Klaviyo or HubSpot require similar export processes, though the exact steps may vary. Always verify that the exported file includes:
- Email addresses (required)
- First/last names (recommended)
- Custom fields (e.g., purchase history, preferences)
- Opt-in dates and consent records [2]
Next, clean and segment your data to avoid compliance violations:
- Remove inactive or unengaged contacts: Archive contacts who haven’t opened emails in 6+ months to reduce bounce rates [2].
- Import suppression lists separately: Upload unsubscribed, bounced, or complained contacts as a suppression list to prevent accidental re-emailing [2].
- Reconfirm old contacts: For contacts collected before GDPR/CCPA, send a re-confirmation email via Mailchimp’s signup forms to ensure explicit consent [2].
Finally, authenticate your domain to improve inbox placement:
- Set up SPF (Sender Policy Framework) and DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) records in your DNS settings. Mailchimp provides step-by-step guides for this process [2].
- Enable 2-factor authentication (2FA) on your Mailchimp account to protect against unauthorized access [2].
During Migration: Importing and Structuring Data
With prepared data, the next step is importing contacts into Mailchimp and organizing them for effective campaign management. Mailchimp’s interface supports CSV uploads, direct integrations, and API-based transfers.
Importing contacts:
- Navigate to Audience > All Contacts > Import Contacts in your Mailchimp dashboard.
- Select CSV or TXT file and upload your exported data. Mailchimp’s system will map fields automatically, but manually verify that custom fields (e.g., "Customer Tier" or "Last Purchase Date") align correctly [9].
- For large lists (>10,000 contacts), use batch importing or Mailchimp’s API to avoid timeouts [1].
- Avoid duplicate entries by enabling Mailchimp’s "Update existing contacts" option during import [5].
Structuring your audience:
- Use a single audience for most use cases, as Mailchimp’s pricing is contact-based, not list-based. Multiple audiences can lead to higher costs and fragmented data [1] [5].
- Organize contacts with tags and groups:
- Tags (e.g., "VIP," "Black Friday 2023") for temporary or behavioral segmentation.
- Groups (e.g., "Product Interest: Electronics") for static categories [1].
- Segments (e.g., "Opened last 3 emails") for dynamic, rule-based filtering.
- Recreate automations and templates:
- Export HTML from your old platform’s email templates and import them into Mailchimp’s Template Builder. Test responsiveness before sending [5].
- Rebuild automated workflows (e.g., welcome series, abandoned cart emails) using Mailchimp’s Customer Journey tool. Note that some triggers (e.g., Shopify purchases) require reconfiguring integrations [5].
Post-import checks:
- Verify that custom fields (e.g., "Loyalty Points") appear in contact profiles.
- Run a test send to a small segment (5–10 contacts) to confirm deliverability and rendering.
- Check the Audience Dashboard for import errors (e.g., invalid emails) and resolve them before launching campaigns [1].
Post-Migration: Engagement and Optimization
After migrating, focus on re-engaging your audience and monitoring performance to maintain sender reputation. Mailchimp’s analytics tools help identify issues early.
Re-engagement strategies:
- Send a "welcome back" email to active contacts, introducing any changes (e.g., new sending frequency, exclusive content). For example:
> "We’ve moved to Mailchimp to bring you better emails! Here’s what’s new..." [2].
- Target inactive contacts with a reactivation campaign. Offer an incentive (e.g., 10% off) and include a clear unsubscribe link to clean your list further [2].
- Gradually increase send volume: Start with 20–30% of your list to avoid triggering spam filters, then scale up over 2–4 weeks [2].
Monitoring and maintenance:
- Track deliverability metrics (open rates, bounce rates, spam complaints) in Mailchimp’s Reports section. Aim for:
- Bounce rate < 2%.
- Spam complaints < 0.1% [2].
- Reauthenticate your domain if you notice drops in inbox placement.
- Update integrations: Reconnect CRM tools (e.g., Shopify, Salesforce) via Mailchimp’s Integrations Directory to ensure data syncs correctly [5].
Ongoing best practices:
- Regularly clean your list: Archive unengaged contacts every 6 months.
- Use double opt-in for new signups to maintain list quality.
- Leverage Mailchimp’s support: Paid users can access email/chat support for migration-related issues [1].
Sources & References
mailchimp.com
mailchimp.com
Discussions
Sign in to join the discussion and share your thoughts
Sign InFAQ-specific discussions coming soon...